Separated At Birth
For weeks now I've been watching this Nike commercial and I couldn't shake this nagging feeling that I'd seen one of the players before. The more I watched it, the more confounded I became. Luckily, due to a sweet photo spread of pro basketball players and the tang they pull I was able to arrive at a conclusion.
I'm fairly certain Shawn Marion and the fauno from "Pan's Labyrinth" were switched at birth. 
I stand by my hypothesis, and humbly offer one more case of Separated At Birth after the jump.
This one's obscure, but I have an unabashed love for the 90's Duke teams. Eventually, JJ Redick taught me how to hate.
Irregardless: Cherokee Parks and obscure Bill Pullman role of Daryl Zero might have been separated at birth:
